If the cell manufacturer can deliver cells with a proven quality history of OCV within +/-0.02V then you will be able to assemble and charge these cells without gross balancing. However, you will need to consider a. This is what you are probably trying to avoid as it can take hours or even days for the pack balancing to remove large SoC differences. An SoC difference of 10% on a 100Ah cell will ta. This is the approach used by the satellite industry and adopted by motorsport. The cells undergo a number of checks from visual inspection, capacity and internal resistance meas. Similar to option 3, but using just OCV to group cells such that the initial SoC of the cells in a pack will not require gross balancing. This does mean that you need to measure the volt. Prior to assembling the battery packs you can charge/discharge all of the cells to a defined voltage. This ensures all of the cells are matched in SoC prior to assembly.
[PDF Version]
What makes a good battery pack?
Battery packs with well-matched cells perform better than those in which the cell or group of cells differ in serial connection. Quality Li-ion cells have uniform capacity and low self-discharge when new. Adding cell balancing is beneficial especially as the pack ages and the performance of each cell decreases at its own pace.
Only active balancing methods can compensate for “lost” stack capacity due to cell mismatch. Cell to cell mismatch may severely reduce the usable battery stack capacity unless the cells are balanced.
What happens after balancing a battery?
After balancing, the capacity of a battery is limited at both ends by the cell with the lowest capacity (or, in extreme cases, by the cell with the highest internal resistance) A balanced battery is one in which, at some State Of Charge, all the cells are exactly at the same SOC. This can be done at any SOC level.
When should a battery pack be balanced?
Assuming the battery pack will be balanced the first time it is charged and in use. Also, assuming the cells are assembled in series. If the cells are very different in State of Charge (SoC) when assembled the Battery Management System (BMS) will have to gross balance the cells on the first charge.
As in single-cell applications, careful control of the charging and monitoring of the cells is essential to ensure safe operation and prevent premature aging or damage to the battery. However, unlike single-cell systems, series-connected battery stacks need cell balancing.
Does a battery balancing circuit work?
A battery expert once said: “I have not seen a cell balancing circuit that works.” For multi-cell packs, he suggested using quality Li-ion cells that have been factory-sorted on capacity and voltage. This works well for Li-ion packs up to 24V; packs above 24V should have balancing.